Recruit CRM vs Recruiterflow vs Shortlists: Which Fits a 3-to-10 Seat UK Agency?
Choose Recruit CRM if contract billing, UK job-board aggregators or a 30-day trial matter most. Choose Recruiterflow if you want unlimited records, sequences and sales automation in one listed price and can price the AI separately. Choose Shortlists if you run a permanent 3-to-10 seat UK desk and want business development signals, a notetaker and a client portal in one month-to-month price.
Key takeaways
- On monthly billing, Recruit CRM lists Pro at $109, Business at $159 and Enterprise at $259 per user a month. With annual billing, the rates fall to $95, $135 and $215 respectively. Recruiterflow lists its Platform plan at $149 per user a month on monthly billing, with its AIRA agents on a quote-only plan. Shortlists is $99 per user a month for 1 to 9 seats on monthly billing. (Sources: Vendor pricing pages, checked 3 November 2026; Recruit CRM's monthly prices also confirmed against published monthly-billing rate cards.)
- At five seats, 12 months on monthly billing cost $5,940 for Shortlists, $6,540 for Recruit CRM Pro, $8,940 for Recruiterflow Platform and $9,540 for Recruit CRM Business. Shortlists has the lowest published starting price on this like-for-like billing basis. Recruit CRM Pro has pooled credits and limits on custom pipeline configurations.
- Credits can change the Recruit CRM bill: LinkedIn messaging and WhatsApp for every seat of a five-seat Pro account require 1,250 credits against 500 included, leaving a 750-credit monthly shortfall. The actual purchase price of extra credits needs confirming.
- Recruiterflow's notetaker, matcher and job change alerts sit on the quote-only AIRA plan, while Shortlists includes the AI notetaker, BD Radar and a client portal in its $99 price.
- If you are tied into another CRM contract, Shortlists costs $51 per user a month until that term ends.
Who each tool is built for: Contract staffing, search firms and small permanent desks
Recruit CRM positions itself across permanent, executive search, contract staffing, RPO and corporate recruitment, and says it serves more than 2,000 agencies in over 100 countries. Recruiterflow describes its entry plan as created for search firms that need a complete system, and its currency selector offers dollars, euros and pounds. (Sources: Vendor pages.) Shortlists is built only for 3-to-10 seat UK agencies doing permanent recruiting.
None of that makes one better in the abstract. A tool built for many recruiting models offers breadth, and a tool built for one gives it fewer choices to configure. The rest of this comparison tests that trade-off on price, inclusions and the effort of moving in.
List prices in dollars: Recruit CRM, Recruiterflow and Shortlists plan by plan
| Plan | Billed monthly (per user/month) | Billed annually (monthly equivalent) | What the plan includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Recruit CRM Pro | $109 | $95 | 1 hiring pipeline |
| Recruit CRM Business | $159 | $135 | 100 hiring pipelines |
| Recruit CRM Enterprise | $259 | $215 | 100 hiring pipelines |
| Recruiterflow Platform | $149 | $119* | ATS and CRM, sequences, recruitment and sales automation, access control, Chrome sourcing, reports, API, unlimited jobs, candidates, contacts and companies |
| Recruiterflow AIRA | Custom quote | Custom quote | Platform plus AI notetaker, matchmaker, job change alerts, field updates, submission and task agents, omnichannel sync, custom BI |
| Shortlists All Access | $99 | $84 (annual billing) | 1 to 9 seats: CRM and ATS, BD Radar, AI notetaker, client portal, outreach, API and 100 credits per seat a month |
| Shortlists Enterprise | Custom quote | Custom quote | 10 or more seats, priced by team size and credits |
All prices are in US dollars, per user per month, excluding taxes and usage-based charges. 'Billed annually' shows the effective monthly rate when the annual term is paid for. Recruit CRM's monthly-billing prices of $109, $159 and $259 per user are also listed on TrustRadius. Its official pricing page shows the lower annual-billing rates by default. Recruiterflow's own 2026 ATS pricing guide lists its Platform plan at $119 per user per month billed annually, or $149 with monthly billing.
What three, five and eight seats cost a year: Like-for-like billing terms
The tables below show 12 months of licence fees in US dollars, before taxes, additional credits, paid AI plans and migration fees. For monthly billing, they total 12 monthly payments. For annual billing, they use the discounted monthly-equivalent rate paid on an annual term.
Monthly billing: total over 12 months
| Tool and plan | 3 seats | 5 seats | 8 seats |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shortlists at $99/user/month | $3,564 | $5,940 | $9,504 |
| Recruit CRM Pro at $109/user/month | $3,924 | $6,540 | $10,464 |
| Recruiterflow Platform at $149/user/month | $5,364 | $8,940 | $14,304 |
| Recruit CRM Business at $159/user/month | $5,724 | $9,540 | $15,264 |
Annual billing: total for the annual term
| CRM | 3 seats | 5 seats | 8 seats |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shortlists, $84 annual | $3,024 | $5,040 | $8,064 |
| Recruit CRM Pro, $95 annual | $3,420 | $5,700 | $9,120 |
| Recruiterflow Platform, $119 annual | $4,284 | $7,140 | $11,424 |
| Recruit CRM Business, $135 annual | $4,860 | $8,100 | $12,960 |
Recruiterflow's annual rate should be reconfirmed at quote stage. All totals are seat price multiplied by seat count and 12, with no allowance for extra credits or quote-only services.
At five seats, Shortlists on monthly billing costs $600 less per year than Recruit CRM Pro, $3,000 less than Recruiterflow Platform and $3,600 less than Recruit CRM Business. On annual billing, Shortlists costs $660 less than Recruit CRM Pro, $2,100 less than Recruiterflow Platform and $3,060 less than Recruit CRM Business. These are published licence-price comparisons, not predictions of total cost or feature-for-feature equivalents.
How Recruit CRM credits change the bill for a five-seat agency
Recruit CRM pools credits across the account and gives each seat a monthly allowance: 100 on Pro, 200 on Business and 2,000 on Enterprise. The page values 100 credits at $10 and says extra credits can be bought, without listing their price. Using the page's own valuation, credit-based features cost the following.
| Feature that draws on credits | Credits listed | At the page's valuation |
|---|---|---|
| Advanced analytics | 300 per user a month | $30 per user a month |
| LinkedIn messaging and project sync | 150 per user a month | $15 per user a month |
| WhatsApp messaging | 100 per user a month | $10 per user a month |
| Job multiposting | 25 per unique job | $2.50 per job |
| Timesheets for contractors | From 100 per active contractor a month, tiered by contractor count | From $10 per contractor a month |
A five-seat Pro account that uses LinkedIn messaging and WhatsApp for every seat needs 1,250 credits a month against 500 included, a shortfall of 750 credits. The monthly-billing licence baseline for these five seats is $6,540 over 12 months, before extra credits. The page's credit valuation is not a confirmed top-up purchase price, so the actual additional charge needs to be checked. Shortlists lists 100 credits per seat a month, pooled across the team, alongside the notetaker, BD Radar and client portal as inclusions of its $99 price.
What each price includes: AI notetaker, client portal, business development signals and temp support
| Need | Recruit CRM | Recruiterflow | Shortlists |
|---|---|---|---|
| AI call notetaker | Listed from Pro, draws on credits | On the quote-only AIRA plan | Included |
| Client-facing portal | Hiring manager portal from Pro | Not listed on the pricing page | Branded client portal included |
| Hiring signals for business development | Job change and backdoor hiring alerts, on credits | Job change alerts on AIRA | BD Radar scans funding, leadership moves, senior leavers and posting spikes |
| Contact enrichment | 1 to 4 credits per record | Phone and email finder on AIRA | Via the 100 credits per seat a month |
| Temp and contract billing | Timesheets and contractor billing, on credits | Not listed on the pricing page | Not supported |
| Open API | Business and above | Entry plan | Included |
| UK job-board aggregators | LogicMelon, Broadbean and CV-Library on Business | Not listed on the pricing page | Not listed |
"Not listed" means the item does not appear on the vendor's pricing page as checked on 3 November 2026; confirm with the vendor. Shortlists column: Its pricing page and BD Radar page.
Recruit CRM is the only one of the three that lists contractor timesheets and UK aggregator feeds, which settles the question for a mixed temp and permanent desk. For permanent work, the difference is where the AI sits. Recruit CRM meters it in credits, Recruiterflow prices it by quote, and Shortlists includes it, as set out in how the AI interview notetaker works.
Migration, trials and contracts compared: What it takes to move a desk onto each tool
| Moving in | Recruit CRM | Recruiterflow | Shortlists |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-serve import | CSV import tool | Excel or CSV import, free | Run by the Shortlists team |
| Assisted migration | Paid | Paid, typically 6 to 8 weeks | Free, typically 2 to 3 weeks |
| Trial | 30 days on Pro and Business | Demo-led; no trial on the page | 7 days, card required |
| Billing | Monthly or annual toggle | Monthly or annual toggle | Monthly, or annual with 15% off |
Sources: The three vendors' pricing pages and the Shortlists switching page, checked 3 November 2026.
The cost of moving in is easy to miss in a licence comparison. Paid assisted migration and a 6 to 8 week timeline change when a desk is productive, whereas the Shortlists team runs free data migration.
When Recruit CRM or Recruiterflow is the better choice for a small UK agency
Recruit CRM is worth considering if you bill contractors weekly, post to UK aggregators, or want a longer trial before committing. Its Pro plan starts at $109 per user a month on monthly billing, compared with Shortlists at $99, and may still be the better fit when its contract-staffing capabilities matter to your desk. Its custom pipeline and field limits should be checked against your workflow.
Recruiterflow is the stronger fit if you want unlimited jobs, candidates, contacts and companies, sequences and sales automation in one listed price, and you are comfortable pricing its AI agents by quote. Shortlists does not handle temp desks, timesheets or shift scheduling, so a mixed desk should look elsewhere, and our ranking of ATS options for small UK agencies sets out where each tool fits.
How to choose between the three in four questions
Do you bill contractors or only place permanent staff? How many different hiring pipeline configurations does your agency need? Which AI features do you use every week, and are they inside the price or metered? And what will moving in cost in time as well as money? The answers usually settle the choice before price does. For the pricing models behind them, see how recruiting CRM pricing works, and for the extra tools a cheaper seat can leave out, the cost of stacking separate tools.
What Shortlists costs, how the $51 bridge works and what migration includes
Shortlists is $99 per user a month for 1 to 9 seats, with annual billing saving 15% and no annual contract required. The price includes BD Radar, which scans for hiring signals so you can get to the hiring manager before the job is posted. Full details are on the Shortlists pricing page.
If another CRM contract is still running, Shortlists costs $51 per user a month until it ends, then moves to the standard price. We respect the craft, so the software takes the admin and your recruiters keep the judgement that wins placements. Our guide to recruiting CRMs for small UK agencies compares the wider field.
Frequently asked questions
What does "unlimited" mean on each plan, and where do limits still bite?
Recruiterflow's Platform plan lists unlimited jobs, candidates, contacts and companies. That describes the number of records in those categories, not access to every AI feature: Recruiterflow's AIRA agents are priced separately by quote. Recruit CRM's pricing page lists one hiring pipeline on Pro and 100 on Business and Enterprise. Its credit-based features also have usage allowances, so unlimited records should not be confused with unlimited pipelines or unlimited AI usage.
Which of the three tells you the price of its AI before you talk to sales?
Recruit CRM publishes credit costs per feature, such as 3 credits per 100 profiles for AI sourcing and 1 to 4 credits per enriched record. Recruiterflow publishes no price for its AIRA agents, and the notetaker, matchmaker and job change alerts sit behind that quote. Shortlists includes its AI features and 100 credits per seat a month in the $99 price.
Can any of the three run contractor timesheets and billing?
Recruit CRM lists timesheets and contractor billing on every plan, charged in credits per active contractor each month, from 100 credits per contractor and tiered by contractor count. Recruiterflow's pricing page lists no timesheets, and Shortlists does not support temp or contract billing.
Which UK job boards can each tool post to?
Recruit CRM names LogicMelon, Broadbean and CV-Library as aggregators on Business and above, plus 10 custom job feeds. Neither Recruiterflow nor Shortlists names UK aggregators on its pricing page, so confirm the boards you rely on before you commit.
Is a trial the same as a demo when you compare them?
No. Recruit CRM offers a 30-day trial on Pro and Business and sells Enterprise through a demo. Recruiterflow's page offers a demo only. Shortlists offers a 7-day trial with a card required, and a migration call can run the trial while the team moves your data.
Can I move from Recruit CRM or Recruiterflow before my contract ends?
Yes. Shortlists costs $51 per user a month until your existing term ends, and you remain liable for the old contract. There is more on how the bridge rate works when you plan the timing.
Price the plan you would actually use, then test the finalists on your own records
List the features your desk uses every week, price them on each tool including credits and AI plans, and trial two finalists on a live role. Shortlists is built for 3-to-10 seat UK agencies and used by 55+ UK recruitment agencies.
- Start your 7-day free trial and see how your records sit in it before you commit to anything.
- Book a demo and we will map the migration around your existing term.
Sources (all checked 3 November 2026)
Recruit CRM plans, prices, credits, limits, inclusions, trial and migration: Recruit CRM pricing. Published in US dollars.
Recruiterflow plans, prices, inclusions, AIRA plan and migration: Recruiterflow pricing. Published in US dollars, with a currency selector.
Shortlists price, inclusions, seat bands, annual saving and bridge rate: Shortlists pricing and BD Radar, where the dollar price is shown. Migration process and timeline: Shortlists switching page.